| Individual | Induction Year |
| Mike Annala | 1998 |
Tom Fajardo
Chris Jaurique
Jerry Loftin | 1999 |
Tim Kelley
Daren Fridge | 2000 |
| John Hughes | 2001 |
Chris Wadleigh
John Tortolani | 2002 |
Marco Cano
John Zerbe | 2003 |
Marcus Rome
Jon Ventress
Joe Latulippe | 2004 |
Dallas Hartley
Ryan Horn
Pat Ferguson
Graham Elsdon | 2005 |
Oliver Day
Chris Everett | 2006 |
| none | 2007 |
Mike Fritz
Nick Sherrell | 2008 |
Ben Alexander
Will Burson
MJ Crickmore
Dominic Gomez | 2009 |
Doug Carl
Chris Esposito | 2010 |
Jamey Dale
Brain Johnson | 2011 |
| Jeff Virden | 2012 |
Cito Williams
Warren Pringle | 2013 |
| Phil Keebler | 2014 |
none
| 2015 |
| Dan McDonald | 2016 |
Postponed Due To Fires
| 2017 |
Jordan Ambler
Mike Sylvester | 2018 |
Ryan Heidrich
Dan Riddle
Matt Gillan | 2019 |
| Postponed Due to COVID-19 | 2020 |
| - | 2021 |
| - | 2022 |
| - | 2023 |
| - | 2024 |
| - | 2025 |
